To Readers: I don’t normally include guest posts on this platform, however due to the incredibly important nature of Cynthia Chung’s brilliant new report on the deeper historical forces shaping the current crisis in Ukraine, and the world more broadly going back over 1000 years to the early days of Kievan Rus, I decided to circulate it here.
Lorenz Kraus's comment is psychopathic. Next thing you know, he will be saying Hitler was greatly misunderstood and if you are not German you are not allowed to criticize.
According to Lorenz's laws, if you are not of the same race you can only be supportive and not critical of actions of an ethnic grouping even if those actions are committing an ethnic genocide in their region.
The Saker has also published an article on how the Pentagon, U.S. media, etc., have in fact employed a “strategy” of outright lying and making up fake intelligence to ‘combat Russia’ called Sitrep: Operation Z/6. https://thesaker.is/sitrep-operation-z-6/
An eye opener of your research when senses overlook nazism is the Dulles' CIA Aerodynamics archive. If not via GMU these past decades, then progressive Virginia, w/Amnesty Int'l, scary emigre CIA, New York port recruiting, sanctions on Rus diplomats, daughters and so on.
Captures UKR diaspora as well on Scythian people, balkanization and irrational hatred.
I thank you profusely for sharing Cynthia’s Ukarainian history essay.
Do you or Cynthia have works that address the historic and recent divisions between Roman Catholics, Greek Catholic-Uniates, Ukrainian Orthodox jurisdictions who proclaim fealty to Patriarch Bartholomew I in Instanbul, and Ukrainian Orthodox jurisdictions who look to Kirill I of Moscow? Have you any maps that present the divisions by geography?
I understand that Bartholomew I has bent toward Washington for political reasons. Does Moscow remain “The Third Rome,” and seat of Pravin-slavnyy Orthodox Christianity? Or, as Ivan Karamazov described, has the Russian Orthodox Church slouched toward the state, in your opinion?
If you think politics are all identity politics, where does that put the transgender identity people who change identity at will? Is there no level at which higher values work above fighting about stereotypes like 'Russian rapists'? You are catering to the worst in human nature, just like the guys who work for the Empire of lies to make money and care about nothing else. Is that why you are on here, to discredit those with actual higher values than merely fighting over who speaks what varieties of words and if they eat perogies or some other form of potato filled dumplings with onions? It's all just ludicrous, all this identity politics, it's all so easily manipulated by the schemers that operate in empires, the Sorosians et al. The reality is that the schemers always want guys like you out there putting stupid ideas into the heads of people to get them to fight their neighbors instead of asking who is paying the asshole, and why he/you are so well paid and why you aren't being questioned about YOUR benefactors? This is the same kind of stupidity that allowed so called witches to be burned at the stake -- who was questioning those who wanted to burn people alive in the first place??? People are wising up to this tactic. We are looking at the manipulators, the liars, the schemers, and looking at who is paying them, and we are looking at you and saying, who are YOU? and why do YOU want to spread stupid ideas that promote division that always only works for weapons manufacturers, bankers and hedge funds? No. It's time to rise above being manipulated by the dividers and ask who you work for when you do this stuff.
Great response Shannon! It is incredible the duplicity of a Lorenz who makes the claim that Ukrainians will always be victims after Cynthia Chung uses actual declassified material from the OSS, CIA and so forth to showcase that Ukrainians supporting OUN (who were and are numerous) were guilty of pogroms, collaboration with the Nazis and crimes on par with Japan's Unit 731. Why is he not bringing up the crimes the Ukrainians committed against the Poles and the Jews? Is this all justified in his narrative, the Ukrainians have the right to commit ethnic genocide and if you aren't Ukrainian you should stay out of it?!?
Right so anybody who is not an ethnic Ukrainian or German deserves to be slaughtered if they live in those countries and Ukrainians and Germans ALSO have the right to kill OTHER Ukrainians and Germans that disagree, all for their self-defense? Did you even read the article? You claim that everyone else is to blame, are you not going to take responsibility for the needless slaughter that occurred under the Nazis and OUN? They didn't just kill Russians, Poles and Jews they also killed Ukrainians, even their own membership. There was significant infighting within the OUN such that they killed thousands of their own members. Do you think torture and mutilation is also in self-defense? Committed by most notably the SS Galician Division but the UPA as well. You are living in a serial killer's fantasy land. Anyone who thinks they are justified to act out these views should be put in a psychiatric ward.
Why are you calling everyone who disagrees with you a Larouchian? You appear to be getting Shannon mixed up with the writer of this article who is Cynthia Chung, is it that easy for you to get confused? Also, Shannon was not trumpeting transgender rights, she was bringing up the fallacy of identity politics, which you Lorenz are trumpeting but through an ethnocentric lens. By the way, there is no such thing as a "pure" race. And most people in the world are ethnically mixed. Again in your simpleton view of the world, I checked out your substack page, you believe that white supremacy can end if everyone were to just stick with their ethnic groups? Are you mad? Why should we be forced into such restrictions? Is that empowerment, is that freedom? And what are those who are mixed ethnicity and choose to be with others who are not of their ethnicity supposed to do in such a world? Is the slaughter of these people justified in your eyes? What a monstrous world you wish to live in!!! By the way, the CIA worked with the German and Ukrainian Nazis. Gehlen being brought in by the CIA to oversee West Germany is the most notorious example of this. MK Ultra was under Allen Dulles who was also working closely with the Nazis during WWII and afterwards. MK Ultra is a branch from Tavistock. So no, the German Nazis are certainly not the victim here. You can make up all the "secret" history you want Lorenz, but at the end of the day you are not the hero - you are the monster. You need to look in the mirror and deal with some issues.
Thank you, Cynthia, for this excellent piece. Your detail is really impressive. I'm looking forward to the next installment!
Lorenz Kraus's comment is psychopathic. Next thing you know, he will be saying Hitler was greatly misunderstood and if you are not German you are not allowed to criticize.
According to Lorenz's laws, if you are not of the same race you can only be supportive and not critical of actions of an ethnic grouping even if those actions are committing an ethnic genocide in their region.
Lorenz should take a lesson from these comedians. "Are We the Baddies?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU
Caitlin Johnstone just published a great article on her substack "US Officials Admit They’re Literally Just Lying To The Public About Russia." https://caitlinjohnstone.substack.com/p/us-officials-admit-theyre-literally?s=r
The Saker has also published an article on how the Pentagon, U.S. media, etc., have in fact employed a “strategy” of outright lying and making up fake intelligence to ‘combat Russia’ called Sitrep: Operation Z/6. https://thesaker.is/sitrep-operation-z-6/
Why condescend to being the arbiter of guest posting. Because after all, you are a Canadian patriot.
An eye opener of your research when senses overlook nazism is the Dulles' CIA Aerodynamics archive. If not via GMU these past decades, then progressive Virginia, w/Amnesty Int'l, scary emigre CIA, New York port recruiting, sanctions on Rus diplomats, daughters and so on.
Captures UKR diaspora as well on Scythian people, balkanization and irrational hatred.
Fascinating article, thankyou. Are any of you professional Historians able to comment on the veracity/implications of the 10,000 BC Mezine/ Ukranian Swastika? ( https://archive.org/details/TheOriginOfTheSwastikaOldestKnownSwastikaFoundInUkraineCa10000BCE )
Dear Matt:
I thank you profusely for sharing Cynthia’s Ukarainian history essay.
Do you or Cynthia have works that address the historic and recent divisions between Roman Catholics, Greek Catholic-Uniates, Ukrainian Orthodox jurisdictions who proclaim fealty to Patriarch Bartholomew I in Instanbul, and Ukrainian Orthodox jurisdictions who look to Kirill I of Moscow? Have you any maps that present the divisions by geography?
I understand that Bartholomew I has bent toward Washington for political reasons. Does Moscow remain “The Third Rome,” and seat of Pravin-slavnyy Orthodox Christianity? Or, as Ivan Karamazov described, has the Russian Orthodox Church slouched toward the state, in your opinion?
Peter N
My Brother in law might help you... https://www.regents.ac.uk/about/our-people/professor-tom-villis#publications
If you think politics are all identity politics, where does that put the transgender identity people who change identity at will? Is there no level at which higher values work above fighting about stereotypes like 'Russian rapists'? You are catering to the worst in human nature, just like the guys who work for the Empire of lies to make money and care about nothing else. Is that why you are on here, to discredit those with actual higher values than merely fighting over who speaks what varieties of words and if they eat perogies or some other form of potato filled dumplings with onions? It's all just ludicrous, all this identity politics, it's all so easily manipulated by the schemers that operate in empires, the Sorosians et al. The reality is that the schemers always want guys like you out there putting stupid ideas into the heads of people to get them to fight their neighbors instead of asking who is paying the asshole, and why he/you are so well paid and why you aren't being questioned about YOUR benefactors? This is the same kind of stupidity that allowed so called witches to be burned at the stake -- who was questioning those who wanted to burn people alive in the first place??? People are wising up to this tactic. We are looking at the manipulators, the liars, the schemers, and looking at who is paying them, and we are looking at you and saying, who are YOU? and why do YOU want to spread stupid ideas that promote division that always only works for weapons manufacturers, bankers and hedge funds? No. It's time to rise above being manipulated by the dividers and ask who you work for when you do this stuff.
Great response Shannon! It is incredible the duplicity of a Lorenz who makes the claim that Ukrainians will always be victims after Cynthia Chung uses actual declassified material from the OSS, CIA and so forth to showcase that Ukrainians supporting OUN (who were and are numerous) were guilty of pogroms, collaboration with the Nazis and crimes on par with Japan's Unit 731. Why is he not bringing up the crimes the Ukrainians committed against the Poles and the Jews? Is this all justified in his narrative, the Ukrainians have the right to commit ethnic genocide and if you aren't Ukrainian you should stay out of it?!?
Right so anybody who is not an ethnic Ukrainian or German deserves to be slaughtered if they live in those countries and Ukrainians and Germans ALSO have the right to kill OTHER Ukrainians and Germans that disagree, all for their self-defense? Did you even read the article? You claim that everyone else is to blame, are you not going to take responsibility for the needless slaughter that occurred under the Nazis and OUN? They didn't just kill Russians, Poles and Jews they also killed Ukrainians, even their own membership. There was significant infighting within the OUN such that they killed thousands of their own members. Do you think torture and mutilation is also in self-defense? Committed by most notably the SS Galician Division but the UPA as well. You are living in a serial killer's fantasy land. Anyone who thinks they are justified to act out these views should be put in a psychiatric ward.
Why are you calling everyone who disagrees with you a Larouchian? You appear to be getting Shannon mixed up with the writer of this article who is Cynthia Chung, is it that easy for you to get confused? Also, Shannon was not trumpeting transgender rights, she was bringing up the fallacy of identity politics, which you Lorenz are trumpeting but through an ethnocentric lens. By the way, there is no such thing as a "pure" race. And most people in the world are ethnically mixed. Again in your simpleton view of the world, I checked out your substack page, you believe that white supremacy can end if everyone were to just stick with their ethnic groups? Are you mad? Why should we be forced into such restrictions? Is that empowerment, is that freedom? And what are those who are mixed ethnicity and choose to be with others who are not of their ethnicity supposed to do in such a world? Is the slaughter of these people justified in your eyes? What a monstrous world you wish to live in!!! By the way, the CIA worked with the German and Ukrainian Nazis. Gehlen being brought in by the CIA to oversee West Germany is the most notorious example of this. MK Ultra was under Allen Dulles who was also working closely with the Nazis during WWII and afterwards. MK Ultra is a branch from Tavistock. So no, the German Nazis are certainly not the victim here. You can make up all the "secret" history you want Lorenz, but at the end of the day you are not the hero - you are the monster. You need to look in the mirror and deal with some issues.