Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JohnIs's avatar

“Those Wall Street industrialists and financiers that supplied Germany with funding and supplies before and during the war were punished”

Did you mean to say “were not punished”?

Expand full comment
Steve Naidamast's avatar

In present day discussions it appears that we forget that the Stalinist Russia cannot be compared in any way to today's Russian Federation. As a result, we continue to demonize the National Socialists who invaded Russia both for Lebensraum (which was actually to only include a part of Ukraine) but also to eradicate Bolshevism, which was moving swift;y to swallow the entirety of Europe.

By the middle of 1940, German Intelligence already knew that Stalin had plans to invade Germany and move on from there to be in Italy by 1942.

By June of 1941, Soviet Russia had conquered Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, half of Poland, Beserabia and Bukovina of Romania, ten percent of Finland whereby Soviet Forces had also occupied the most valuable area of that land mass, the Hako Islands, forced a coup to install a friendly government in Yugoslavia, and was attempting to force Bulgaria into a "friendship treaty", which they did not want.

Despite all of this, The Third Reich was and still is demonized for its very legitimate invasion of Poland in order to stop the increasing violent oppression of its German ethnic minority.

To add insult to injury, Adolf Hitler is constantly seen as a "madman" and have seen US enemy leaders constantly referred to as a new "Hitler".

However, Adolf Hitler was far from mad. He was highly intelligent, was capable of reading a wide swathe of technical and non-technical books on average as one per day and had a personal library of 12,000 books, being one of the largest personal libraries in the world only to be exceeded by Israel's David Ben Gurion who I believe had around 16.000 texts in his.

Adolf Hitler was very capable of speaking intelligently and technically on a very wide array of subjects and had a very deep interest in architecture and architectural design.

He also wasn't half-bad watercolor artist.

Stalin on the other hand was more ruthless than intelligent and was the one who actually broke the 1939 Moscow Pact between the The Third Reich and Soviet Russia by moving massive amounts of hardware and troops right up to the then Reich's 1000 mile borders with the idea that he would invade Germany in July or August of 1941.

There is no doubt that The Third Reich did in fact have plans to invade the Soviet Union as a result of the threat of Bolshevism, which Germany had a visceral hatred for (and rightly so). However, these plans were for June 1941 when Germany did invade the USSR but were initiated as a direct result of Soviet Force movements and mobilizations, which included the massive building of aerodromes, many only around 20 minutes from the Reich's borders.

As a result, Operation Barbarossa was both a planned invasion as well as a per-emptive response to Soviet Russia's threatening invasion of Germany.

Viktor Suvorov has written extensively on this subject. However, Sean McMeekin's recent historical publications, "Stalin's War", corroborates Suvorov's analysis in stark detail in very easy and fast reading prose...

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts